Friday, 21 June 2019

The Most Beautiful Book About Nature-Hoarding


If one was asked to define what 'nature writing' really means, it might be more of a challenge than one might think. I, for one, was asking myself this question while reading The Wild Remedy by Emma Mitchell.

I'm on a bit of a nature writing stint at the moment. I've read nearly the entire backlist of Robert Macfarlane, have dipped into Roger Deakin, have got Nan Shepherd lined up; I've read about figs and oak trees and pebbles, and have had a blast doing it. With this book though, I had to question the very nature of nature writing. Something just wasn't right.

The Wild Remedy declares itself to be a diary, and the idea is so lovely - in a nutshell, Emma Mitchell sets out to explore the healing effects of nature through her own grapple with depression, diarizing her walks with her dog, Annie, and her various adventures in search of natural wonders in the UK. Just the kind of thing that should fit into my above 'starter pack' in nature writing, in theory.

What did I like about it?

It's true that this book looks absolutely stunning. Emma is a talented illustrator and photographer (as well as hoarder of beautiful little things - a true soulmate to me), and the book is peppered with her artwork, illustrating her stories, which I think not enough books in this area do. With other books, I often find myself googling as I go along, looking up plants and animals and places I can hardly imagine; with Emma's book, I didn't have to. I absolutely loved every little piece of art in there.





She has really good knowledge of her local flora and wildlife, as well as those of the areas that she ventures to throughout the book, from Suffolk to Pembrokeshire. Her insider knowledge of bird habits or flowering seasons really helped feel just as excited as she did upon finding a rare wild orchid or seeing the first snowdrops of the year.

What was I not massively fond of?

It's with regret that I have to say that Emma's writing style just did not appeal to me. Sometimes she ventured into that - for me at least - over-sentimental language that sometimes threatened Adam Weymouth too, but unlike Adam, I didn't feel that she could then successfully navigate back to solid ground.

It's most likely unfair for me to say this, but as a reader, I felt that she held back too much detail about her personal life too. For a book that intends to open up honestly about depression and experiencing it day-to-day, it would often only state something like 'something bad had happened' or 'bad periods'. And, due to this, I had trouble identifying with the heaviness of depression itself. Of course, it's easy for me to say I would have been honest about all these things - who knows?

My final bone to pick with Emma is her fondness of technical language when it comes to her depression, which often feels forced. She hovers between a lyrical, poetic work that describes both depression and nature in flowery detail, and presenting research into depression without actually saying much about it. The blurb promises that she "explains the science behind such changes, calling on new research" - none of which really happens in my opinion. She seems very keen on the word 'neurotransmitters', and passages like this made me weary: "My overwhelming urge to stay in the house and barely move comes from my susceptibility to the lower levels of bright sunlight in late autumn and winter, causing my energy levels to falter. This is combined with the long-term effects of family anxieties and pressures, leading to raised stress levels..." It feels a bit like reading a textbook.

I don't mean to criticize the author herself, nor to demean the seriousness of the condition she has to battle every day. I think it all comes down to writing style, which in this case to me felt jarring.

Overall...

It's a shame that I didn't enjoy her style, because the topic of the book is a great one. The execution deserves the highest praise, because despite this being primarily a piece of non-fiction, it would easily pass as a coffee table book. And I'm sure others might enjoy the writing, too. Don't expect to find out much about how nature heals us, apart from the fact that it truly does - which in itself is a miracle - but if you give yourself over to purely the stories of the author's adventures, you will enjoy a pleasant enough read.

5/10

Saturday, 15 June 2019

To The Lighthouse


Have you ever pondered over the fact that we've been to space and the Moon, yet there are still vast areas of ocean floors that we haven't set eyes on? Or that there is such an occupation as 'oceanaut'? I think it says so much about the secretive, elusive and terrifying nature of our waters on Earth - surely something to be respected and feared.

Yet of course, just like the air and land, we have declared victory over our waters too, shipping and cruising across the world for business or pleasure. It seems cocky to think we've got this under control.

The sinking of cargo ship El Faro [the Lighthouse] in October 2015 is the 'proof in the pudding' - a haunting phrase that returns many times towards the end of Into the Raging Sea, the book by Rachel Slade that tells the story of this maritime disaster in detail.

It is a truly fascinating account: using the actual conversations transcribed from the ship's 'black box', we get real insight into the days leading up to the tragedy, and this is accompanied by in-depth analysis of the preceding history and events following the sinking of the ship. I love the back cover copy of this book, because for once it genuinely sums up the contents of the work, and perhaps is worth quoting here in full:

Why did the captain steer directly into a hurricane?
Why did the engines fail?
How could it sink without a single survivor?
Who's responsible?


What did I like about it?

I didn't think the story itself would be as captivating as it turned out to be - don't try selling me something with the word 'megastorm' on the cover - but Slade's powerful narrative works wonders to bring the tragedy alive and to hammer home the significance of such a singularity. It takes an in-depth look at the laws and regulations around shipping in the US, outlining the many areas in which it is lacking, and going deeper into the history of how these regulations developed in the first place.

She also takes good care to present all the major figures from the transcription in detail: backgrounds, interests, employment history, even personal lives are provided for everyone from captain of El Faro Michael Davidson to John Glanfield, retired shipbuilder who took part in the creation of El Faro's 'older sister'.

The human element is well balanced with the technical, and Slade is thorough in every area, which gives the book a satisfying air of professionalism. The years of research she must have carried out comes across bright as day - she knows the story inside out and it seems has spoken to everyone even remotely connected to the tragedy in any way. From how the crew is recruited for voyages through shipbuilding and weather forecasting, she leaves no stone unturned. And this helps people who know absolutely nothing about container shipping - me being a prime example - to not feel left out, but in fact come away with a general idea. And this is what good non-fiction is supposed to do. It makes us care.

What was I not massively fond of?

There are a few points I picked up on throughout the book for this section. Number one being that Slade too often flirts with melodrama in her writing style for my liking. When approaching turning points, short, dramatic sentences and single-sentence paragraphs take charge, and in my opinion cheapen the occurrences to the feeling of a disaster film. "In the whipping winds and waves, Shultz secured the scuttle. But it was too late." "Time slowed to a crawl. The sky began to take shape. Dawn." Of course, this type of dramatic tension is necessary, no debate - but I think a touch of subtlety would have gone a long way.

I also found that perhaps sometimes the technical bits went a bit too in-depth and I found myself zoning out. When discussing the Jones Act, for example (federal law that regulates maritime commerce in the US), we spend a long time on Alexander Hamilton and his role in the creation of the law, as well as its many variations. Interesting and absolutely relevant to the story, no doubt, but perhaps a bit of editing down would have worked in the book's favor.

The blame is also very clear in the book. Slade doesn't shy away from making her opinions known. Of Davidson: "What kind of a man is capable of facing such excessive errors of judgment?" (I mean, fair enough, she is right, but still.) Perhaps the book was written with a purpose more than just education.

Finally, there is a chapter towards the end of the book - 'Spirits' - that I just did not understand. It's only a few pages, but talks about the many 'ghostly' occurrences that family members and friends of the crew of El Faro have experienced after the tragedy. Premonitions, ghostly communications and the like. I would have cut this out entirely.

Overall...

The significance of the sinking of El Faro in maritime history really shows itself in the second part of the book, which deals with the aftermath and trial. US officials are baffled. People who deal with shipping emergencies all day, every day, for decades, are shocked. And it slowly dawns on us how outrageous and unfair it is to have lost 33 lives at sea due to, in large part, bureaucracy. It's frankly disgusting.

This is a well-written account, captivating in every way and, hopefully, influential to the right eyes.

P.S. If you're more the dip into things kind of reader, here's an in-depth article about the tragedy.

7/10

Saturday, 25 May 2019

On beauty and other animals


Until right about now, I didn't even notice the head shape on the cover of my copy of On Beauty by Zadie Smith. My signed copy, I should say - last year, I had the pleasure of attending a talk with Zadie up in north London where, although expecting her new collection of essays to be included in the ticket price, in fact it was a selection of old paperbacks, signed by the author in a hurry before the event. I stepped up to pick up a book at the very best moment, not only because there were only a few copies left (of which this was the only one I hadn't read) but also because I got to watch her sign it. And then smile at her. Even more extravagantly, I asked her a question later on. It was a great event.

Back to the book though! It's been a while since I've read anything from Zadie that I really loved. I read Swing Time last year, but had an awful time doing so. I know that's a divisive book as it is, and I unfortunately was in the camp that didn't like it, or perhaps understood it. After which, I think I got a sort of Zadie Smith-fatigue.

Which is awful of course, considering how incredibly good White Teeth was, which I swiftly followed with N-W, another excellent novel. Writing this, I do wonder if her work has been translated into other languages. If not, why on earth not?

On Beauty tells the story of a few years in the life of a mixed-race, British/American family, and as always, the author doesn't shy away from tackling massive topics in one relatively short book. The issues of culture and national identity, political values, human nature, religion and yes, even beauty, are all tackled through the viewpoints of the family members and other characters whose lives link with the Belseys' in one way or another. It is not light reading, I should warn you.

What did I like about it?

Obviously, Zadie Smith is a literary genius. I wanted to not enjoy this book (due to my earlier mentioned ZS-fatigue), but I couldn't. I feel she could write about pretty much anything - motor cars, the history of mining, rubber tires - and I would still be compelled to read it. She is the master of description, comparable to really no other writer I know of - "A boy called Ron, of delicate build whose movements were tidy and ironic, who liked to be clean, who liked things Japanese. A girl called Daisy, tall and solid like a swimmer, with an all-American ingénue face, sandy hair and more of a salty manner than she required, given her looks..."

On Beauty has a way of making things happen without anything major really happening. The main event is that of the Belsey dad's infidelity - important here because he is white, but also because of his values. Kiki Belsey, the mother, befriends the wife of Monty Kipps, Howard's (the Belsey father) sworn political and professional enemy. One of the Belsey sons becomes religious. The other finds a cause to believe in, one that feels alien to the family. The daughter falls in love. Small, seemingly separate events have a way of interweaving and quietly building up to a heart-wrenching, difficult ending.

The characters are mostly all strong and so human, so believable that I can see the Belseys walking off the page and into my living room. They are all so painfully human, in fact, that their very humanness becomes the plot. They do annoying, stupid things, and they regret them, and they refuse spontaneity and they blackmail.

All these small things add up to a truly captivating read.

What was I not massively fond of?

The one character I struggled with was Victoria Kipps, the daughter of Monty Kipps, who feels a bit shallow at times, a bit difficult to understand, whose motivations are sometimes unclear. To me, she feels a bit like a device - albeit an important one - as if she is dropped into scenes where she is especially needed. None the less, she terrifies me.

My other objections are all human and in no way criticize the novel. Because in some way, it reads like a Russian drama - things that people hope for ultimately don't come true, characters don't act the way they know they should, often things that could change don't change in the end. We root for so many things, but of course, it wouldn't be as good a book if all was well in the end.

I also bloody hated Howard Belsey.

Overall...


Despite the many themes tackled in the novel, to me the strongest was that of a family trying to pull together but desperately failing. It was strong and painful and sad to read.

Zadie is so great at digging deep down into her characters and bringing out the best and the worst. It often feels like a mirror. So of course, this book is often uncomfortable to read. But it is beautiful, well thought-through and addictive, in a way. I remember why I loved her in the first place.

8/10

Saturday, 13 April 2019

Coast to Coast with William Finnegan


A review quote on the back of my copy of Barbarian Days by William Finnegan reads: "I don't know anything about surfing, but I was gripped by the intensity of his language" (Olivia Laing, Guardian). This most likely sums up the experience of many of Finnegan's readers. But I also find this quote near-offensively simplistic.

Finnegan is perhaps best known for being a long-standing staff writer at the New Yorker, reporting often from conflict and war zones, including South America, South Africa and Sudan. So what does it say about his talents that he also won the Pulitzer Prize for biography in 2016 with his 500-page epic, Barbarian Days?

Part-memoir, part travel epic, definitely surf-epic, the book charts Finnegan's journey from childhood to adulthood - a journey in both a physical and chronological sense. To all four corners of the world and back, always chasing the perfect wave, this is a life lived on the road and an adventurous example of how we're always searching for something new. It's a true life, yet reads like a mesmerizing piece of fiction to many of us.

You may be hesitant due to the simple fact that you don't care about surfing, but I would urge you to read on before you make your decision.

Why should you read it?

As all good travel writing, Barbarian Days has more to say than describing waves. If I had to identify a theme, it would have to be something like coming of age - though I'd rather not. Because we might think of coming-of-age books as finished by the age of around 25, while what Finnegan shows is that we never really stop coming of age. After finishing school, he embarks on an epic journey, circumnavigating the globe and stopping at the most isolated spots to surf, seemingly never quite satisfied, always ready to move on to the next best thing. This is the first element that makes the book hugely relatable.

There's also the simple fact that Finnegan's life reads like an adventure novel, albeit a very realistic one. I couldn't help shaking my head almost constantly. At the then uninhabited Tavarua Island in Fiji, he nonchalantly describes coming to grips with the dadakulachi, the three-step snake, so nicknamed due to estimated distance you would be able to make after it bit you (supposedly the world's sixth-deadliest snake). Other times, he writes that "Frequently, there came a moment when I thought, No, never mind, this is getting too heavy, I want to go back to shore. But it was always too late then." Reading about this controversial mind-set he faces almost every time he arrives to shore - the waves are too big, I definitely shouldn't go in, here I go - was one of the best elements of the book, as well as how he learnt to control himself in life-threatening situations and not lose his head. Surfing reads almost like a religion.

It is an in-depth glimpse into the obsession, the philosophy and mind-set of this world, one completely foreign to me. Yet due to his powerful descriptions and awe that shine off the pages, it looped me in. And despite the fact that a life of surfing can leave you mentally and physically impaired, Finnegan keeps coming back to this one constant element of his otherwise rather malleable existence. Like one long, continuous wave, it ebbs and flows throughout the book. 

What was I not massively fond of?

Sure, there were times where for me, the surfing descriptions got a little too long, where I didn't feel as connected to the narrative as before. Some sections are action-packed, and some will just be ordinary days of a life, working and surfing and quarreling and surfing again. But I can hardly complain about the author telling a true story.

Finnegan is honest throughout, and there will be some decisions we may disagree with or scratch our heads in confusion - the logical isn't always the answer. It's hard to imagine that this is only one person's story. Finnegan builds lives in so many different places in the world, only to deconstruct them a month or two later, that he comes to embody almost a spiritual existence, a metaphor of the vagabond. And yet, he's as real as can be. Perhaps it's good for us to read something so far removed from our comfy sofas and daily commutes. 

Overall...

What is the worst way you imagine yourself to die? For me, it is drowning under a giant wave. Nothing is scarier. I've tried surfing once, in knee-high water, and even that was terrifying. So to read a memoir of someone living a life doing the thing that scares me most was a fascinating experience.

Finnegan will make you feel like a newbie, an amateur, a poser; he talks about how surfing went from something completely unknown to 'sport' status, how it became a symbol. Now it's due to be an official sport in the Olympics. So here's an honest account of what it feels like to devote a massive chunk of your life to this obsession, while coming to grips with jobs, settling down, starting a family and what happens to our values in the meantime. 

Despite its exotic aspects, this is not escapism: it is a stressful, beautiful human account of the search.

8/10